Apple has pushed back forcefully against Epic Games’ allegation that it failed to produce over 122,000 documents in their ongoing legal battle over App Store commissions. In a recent filing, Apple insists its document searches have followed the agreements in discovery, arguing that many of the flagged documents are irrelevant due to overbroad search terms.
What’s at Stake
At the center of this dispute is whether Apple must produce documents tied to its proposed 5–15% commission rates on purchases made through external payment systems, a proposal first submitted in August of this year. Epic Games has challenged not only Apple’s commission plan, but also how Apple has handled the discovery process—particularly, how responsive its document production has been under Epic’s requests. Epic asked for internal analyses, communication about strategies to discourage developers from adding link-outs, and searched records of several current and former Apple employees using specific terms. Apple agreed to use Epic’s suggested search terms and target the specified employees. Epic then accused Apple of withholding large numbers of responsive documents, supposedly more than 122,000 items.
Apple’s Defense: Overbroad Searches and Irrelevant “Hits”
In its response, Apple contends that many of the terms Epic insisted on are too generic and drag in irrelevant materials. Apple cites examples like using the wildcard “commission*”—which can pull in “commissioner,” “commissions” but also references to something like the NFL Commissioner. Similarly, the search term “fee*” ended up matching “feel,” “feedback,” “feet,” and other words that have no bearing on the dispute over commission or external payments. Apple claims up to 95% of the documents caught by these search terms lack any discussion of “link-out” or related issues, which are central to what Epic asked for.
Apple further argues that many of the documents flagged are sensitive or private in nature—employee medical or financial records, details about unannounced products, legal materials, passwords, or investor relations discussions. Those types of documents are typically privileged or protected, Apple says, and aren’t required under discovery if they’re not relevant to the core issues. Producing all of them—regardless of relevancy—would be burdensome and would conflict with procedural standards that limit what must be shared.
Epic’s Ask vs. What Apple Offers
Epic wants the court to order Apple to hand over all non-privileged documents that match the shared search terms, no matter whether Apple deemed them relevant. Apple opposes this, arguing that such a move would disrupt agreed-upon discovery rules and would require additional time, especially to filter out privileged content. Apple notes that meeting Epic’s proposed deadline of December 2 is impractical under those conditions.
As a compromise, Apple is offering a randomized sample of documents it considers nonresponsive, to be reviewed by a Special Master—a neutral third party—to assess whether Apple’s relevancy judgments are sound. Apple is asking the court to reject Epic’s motion to produce all matching documents.
This fight unfolds as the Supreme Court considers whether Apple’s “civil contempt” designation in its lawsuit with Epic should be upheld. At the same time, the dispute over commissions and external payment systems could reshape how Apple operates its App Store structure going forward, depending on how the courts rule.
This is more than a courtroom spat over paperwork—it’s about control. Discovery disputes like this can shape what the public, regulators, and developers ultimately see about how Apple designs its payment rules. If Epic succeeds, Apple may be forced to open up more internal deliberations. If Apple wins on this point, it reinforces its ability to maintain tighter control over its App Store policies. Watch the courtroom filings closely: what gets revealed or withheld could have ripple effects across the tech ecosystem.