Apple Warns Canada’s Bill C-22 Threatens User Encryption & Privacy

Apple has joined Big Tech pushback against Canada’s proposed Bill C-22, arguing the legislation still falls short on protecting robust privacy and encryption standards. As the bill nears its final deliberations in the Senate, Apple and peers are urging the government to make further changes before it becomes law.

What Bill C-22 Would Do

Known as the Lawful Access Act, 2026, Bill C-22 aims to give Canadian law enforcement and intelligence agencies expanded power to access certain digital metadata held by electronic service providers (ESPs). Providers could be required to retain this data for up to six months, but not the contents of messages, social media posts, or browsing histories. The legislation insists companies cannot be forced to build “systemic vulnerabilities,” like backdoors, into their systems, particularly in regards to encryption.

Apple’s Position & Industry Backlash

Despite amendments to the bill, Apple has expressed concern that the revised version still undermines the ability to offer essential privacy and security features. The company, along with Google, Meta, Signal and others, argues that the legislation might compel companies to weaken encryption—either by allowing exceptional access to data or by forcing ESPs to hold decryption keys when otherwise they would not.

Signal has even considered pulling its services out of Canada if the bill passes in its current state. Privacy advocates have echoed industry worries, saying the definition of “subscriber information” is overly broad, the requirement for data retention is excessive, and that protections for end-to-end encryption aren’t strong enough.

Government Response & Key Safeguards

The Trudeau government, through Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, acknowledges concerns and insists the bill includes safeguards to protect user data. Officials emphasize that Bill C-22 does not authorize indiscriminate surveillance or force providers to weaken encryption arbitrarily. Only when an ESP created the encryption and retains the key could it be asked to decrypt data—and even then, judicial or intelligence-commissioner-level approval would be required.

Other built-in safeguards include: retention limits for metadata (excluding content); oversight via judicial or intelligence-commissioner review; transparency measures including annual reporting; and strict definitions intended to prevent forced systemic weaknesses in electronic protections.

Privacy Watchdog & Legal Concerns

The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada has weighed in, recommending additional reforms. Particularly, it suggests narrower definitions of subscriber information, clear limitations on who could be compelled to produce data, and greater clarity around what is considered “publicly available information.” A recurring point is that all powers in Bill C-22 should be both necessary and proportionate—requirements some argue are missing or too loosely enforced.

Legal experts and civil-liberties groups warn of downstream risks—from erosion of end-to-end encryption standards to potential cross-border data exposure. U.S. lawmakers have also raised red flags, citing risks to Americans’ data privacy if Canada enacts the legislation as is. Companies like Proton have said expansion into Canada may become untenable under the current framework.

Bill C-22 passed the House of Commons in June 2026 and is now being reviewed by the Senate—its final legislative hurdle before possibly becoming law.

What this means: Apple’s resistance isn’t just about protecting its brand—it reflects broader concerns in tech over how privacy, encryption, and lawful access are being balanced in the digital age. Canada aims to catch up with its Five Eyes and G7 partners by modernizing lawful-access law, but critics say that Bill C-22 still leaves too much room for government overreach.

As the Senate debates this bill, the core questions will be: will Canada definitively protect end-to-end encryption? Will data retention periods be limited strictly and with oversight? And will protections be both effective and enforceable? The legal text may yet shift, but for many, the stakes could not be higher.

Further developments to watch include the Senate committee’s amendments, possible judicial challenges after passage, and how other democracies draw red lines around encryption and metadata in similar bills.