In a significant development within the European Union’s digital marketplace, Apple has revoked the notarization of iTorrent, a popular torrent client, effectively removing it from AltStore PAL, an alternative app marketplace. This action has raised questions about Apple’s control over app distribution, even within third-party platforms.
Background on AltStore PAL and iTorrent
AltStore PAL emerged in response to the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA), which mandated that Apple permit alternative app marketplaces on iOS devices within the EU. Launched in April 2024 by developer Riley Testut, AltStore PAL provided a platform for applications that did not meet Apple’s stringent App Store guidelines. Among the initial offerings were Delta, a Nintendo emulator, and Clip, a clipboard manager. ([theapplewiki.com](https://theapplewiki.com/wiki/AltStore?utm_source=openai))
In July 2024, AltStore PAL expanded its catalog to include third-party applications, notably iTorrent and qBitControl. iTorrent allowed users to download torrent files directly to their iOS devices, while qBitControl served as a remote client for managing qBittorrent on desktop systems. These additions marked a significant shift, as Apple had traditionally prohibited torrenting apps from its official App Store, citing concerns over potential copyright infringements. ([theverge.com](https://www.theverge.com/2024/7/24/24205036/iphone-ios-torrenting-apps-eu-altstore-pal?utm_source=openai))
The Notarization Process and Its Implications
Despite the DMA’s intent to foster a more open app ecosystem, Apple retained a degree of oversight through its notarization process. This procedure involves a baseline review to ensure that apps are free from known malware, viruses, or other security threats. It also verifies that applications function as promised and do not expose users to egregious fraud. ([macrumors.com](https://www.macrumors.com/2025/08/27/apple-blocks-itorrent-app-eu/?utm_source=openai))
In July 2025, users began reporting difficulties in downloading iTorrent from AltStore PAL. The app’s developer, Daniil Vinogradov, discovered that Apple had revoked iTorrent’s alternative distribution rights without prior warning. This revocation effectively blocked the app from appearing on AltStore PAL. ([igeeksblog.com](https://www.igeeksblog.com/apple-pulls-itorrent-altstore-pal-eu/?utm_source=openai))
Vinogradov reached out to Apple Support for clarification but received only generic responses. The matter was escalated internally within Apple, but no specific reasons for the revocation were provided. Similarly, AltStore PAL’s team sought explanations from Apple but encountered the same lack of detailed communication. ([macrumors.com](https://www.macrumors.com/2025/08/27/apple-blocks-itorrent-app-eu/?utm_source=openai))
Apple’s Previous Actions and the Broader Context
This incident is not isolated. In November 2024, Apple rejected the notarization of Mini vMac, a Macintosh emulator intended for distribution via AltStore PAL. The rejection was based on the app’s use of the Mac name and imagery, as well as its promotion of running Apple’s Mac operating system on non-Apple hardware, which violated Apple’s software license terms. ([mjtsai.com](https://mjtsai.com/blog/2024/11/26/mini-vmac-for-ios-rejected-via-notarization/?utm_source=openai))
The revocation of iTorrent’s notarization has sparked debate about the extent of Apple’s control over app distribution, even within third-party marketplaces. While the DMA aimed to reduce Apple’s gatekeeping role, the notarization process allows the company to maintain a level of oversight. This situation raises questions about the balance between ensuring user security and fostering a competitive app ecosystem.
Implications for Developers and Users
For developers, the lack of transparency in Apple’s decision-making process is concerning. Vinogradov expressed frustration over the absence of clear communication, stating, I still have no idea if it was my fault or Apple’s, and their responses make no sense. ([igeeksblog.com](https://www.igeeksblog.com/apple-pulls-itorrent-altstore-pal-eu/?utm_source=openai))
Users are also affected, as the removal of iTorrent limits their choices and access to applications that were previously available. This incident underscores the challenges in navigating the evolving landscape of app distribution within the EU.
Looking Ahead
As of now, iTorrent remains unavailable on AltStore PAL, with no clear timeline for resolution. The situation highlights the ongoing tension between regulatory efforts to open up digital markets and the control exerted by platform owners like Apple. It remains to be seen how this balance will evolve and what it will mean for the future of app distribution in the European Union.
